Skip to main content

Supreme Court of New Zealand — recent judgments: July 2024

/
Content updates

A summary of decisions delivered in July 2024 by the Supreme Court, available on Westlaw New Zealand.

Maid v R  [2024] NZSC 86

31 July 2024

Unsuccessful applications by M for (a) an extension of time to seek leave to appeal against failure by the Court of Appeal to impose a sentence of home detention and (b) leave to appeal against a subsequent refusal to cancel his sentence of imprisonment. The Court of Appeal had reduced his sentence to 17 months’ imprisonment and given him leave to apply for home detention.

 

McFarland v Commissioner of Police  [2024] NZSC 84

30 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by M for leave to appeal against an assets forfeiture order over a property. M was one of three shareholders of the company which owned the property. The shareholders were associated with the Head Hunters motorcycle gang.

 

NZTSOS Inc v Minister for COVID-19 Response  [2024] NZSC 83

30 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by NZTSOSI for leave to appeal against dismissal of its challenge to a vaccination mandate for certain education sector workers in relation to the COVID-19 response.

 

Boyd v Australian Federal Police  [2024] NZSC 82

30 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by B for leave to appeal against the striking out of his appeal as an abuse of process. B had been appealing against the striking out of his proceedings by the High Court.

 

Carter v Capital and Coast District Health Board  [2024] NZSC 85

29 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by C for leave to appeal against the striking out of his proceedings regarding the compulsory mental health treatment received by his son before he died.

 

Deliu v Solicitor-General  [2024] NZSC 81

26 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by D for leave to appeal against a refusal to dispense with security for costs. D had applied for a dispensation in relation to his appeal against dismissal of his application for judicial review.

 

Luo v Shiu  [2024] NZSC 79

24 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by L and others for leave to appeal against a finding that misrepresentations had not been made by S in relation to joint venture agreements.

 

Kumar v R  [2024] NZSC 78

24 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by K for leave to appeal against conviction for theft by a person in a special relationship in relation to grants from gaming machine proceeds.

 

Whakatōhea Kotahitanga Waka (Edwards) v Te Kāhui Takutai Moana o Ngā Whānau me Ngā Hapū o Te Whakatōhea  [2024] NZSC 77

23 July 2024

Successful application by Ngā Hapū o Ngāti Porou to intervene in an appeal in relation to marine and coastal area negotiations.

 

Te Wakaminenga o Nga Hapu ki Waitangi v Waitangi National Trust Board  [2024] NZSC 76

8 July 2024

Unsuccessful application by TWNHW for leave to appeal against refusal by the Registrar of the High Court to accept a statement of claim following reinstatement by the Court of Appeal of TWNHW's proceedings.

 

Chief of Defence Force v Four Members of the Armed Forces  [2024] NZSC 75

8 July 2024

Successful application by CDF and others for leave to appeal against a judgment that had required CDF to reconsider an order made in relation to vaccination against COVID-19.

The approved question was whether the Court of Appeal had been correct to allow an appeal by FMAF.

 

Whittington v UDC Finance Ltd  [2024] NZSC 74

3 July 2024

Unsuccessful applications by W for (a) recall of a judgment issued in 2021 that had refused to stay his bankruptcy adjudication and (b) stay of a High Court order that had adjudicated him bankrupt.

Jane Dawson
By Jane Dawson

Jane Dawson is a Senior Cases Editor in the New Zealand Primary Law team at Thomson Reuters. She completed a LLB at Victoria University in 2018 and also holds degrees in music from Otago University.

Speak to a consultant

Can't find an answer to your question?
Contact our support team.

Request training

Contact our team to arrange training.

Tell us what you think

We'd love to hear what you think
of our products and support.